UNBELIEVABLE NEWS: New York Giants Owners Part Ways with GM Joe Schoen Due to Lack of Professionalism, Inconsistency, and Team’s Downturn.
In a move that has sent shockwaves through the NFL and the New York Giants’ fanbase, the franchise’s ownership has officially parted ways with General Manager Joe Schoen. The decision comes after growing concerns over Schoen’s lack of professional execution, inconsistent decision-making, and the team’s disappointing downturn in recent seasons.
The Giants, once a dominant force in the NFL, have struggled under Schoen’s leadership, leading to an outcry from fans and analysts alike. After enduring a disastrous 2024 season, where the team finished with a 3-14 record, ownership decided that enough was enough. The Mara and Tisch families, who jointly own the franchise, believed that Schoen’s inability to turn things around made it impossible for the team to move forward under his management.
Since taking over as General Manager in January 2022, Joe Schoen was expected to revamp the Giants’ roster and lead the team back to playoff contention. His first year showed promise, as the team made the playoffs in 2022 under head coach Brian Daboll. However, things quickly unraveled.
1. Lack of Professionalism in Decision-Making
One of the biggest criticisms of Schoen has been his poor roster construction and failure to address key issues within the team. His draft selections and free agency signings often failed to meet expectations, with several high-profile acquisitions either underperforming or failing to fit the system.
The offensive line remained a major concern, despite repeated attempts to fix it. Quarterback Daniel Jones, whom Schoen controversially extended with a massive contract, failed to live up to expectations, leaving the team in salary cap turmoil.
2. Inconsistency in Team Management
Schoen’s inability to maintain consistency in the front office and coaching staff also contributed to his downfall. While he initially appeared to have a strong partnership with Brian Daboll, reports emerged of friction between the two regarding personnel decisions.
Additionally, Schoen’s approach to the 2024 trade deadline baffled many fans. Instead of making moves to strengthen the team, he failed to acquire key players or trade assets for future rebuilding, leaving the franchise in a stagnant position.
3. The Downturn of the Franchise
Perhaps the most significant reason for Schoen’s firing was the dramatic collapse of the Giants under his leadership. After making the playoffs in 2022, the team failed to maintain momentum, leading to a disastrous 2023 season (6-11) and an even worse 2024 campaign (3-14).
Fans, who had high hopes after the Giants’ surprising 2022 playoff run, quickly lost faith in Schoen’s vision. The MetLife Stadium crowd grew restless, with chants calling for his removal becoming a common occurrence during home games.
Ownership could no longer ignore the warning signs. With the team in one of its worst states in history, the decision was made to cut ties with Schoen immediately.
The firing of Joe Schoen leaves the Giants searching for a new General Manager, a role that will be critical in reshaping the team’s future. The ownership has emphasized that they will conduct a thorough and strategic search for a candidate who can bring stability, professionalism, and a clear direction back to the franchise.
Potential candidates could include experienced front-office executives from successful teams, such as:
Adam Peters (San Francisco 49ers Assistant GM)
Ed Dodds (Indianapolis Colts Assistant GM)
Joe Hortiz (Baltimore Ravens Director of Player Personnel)
Additionally, the future of head coach Brian Daboll remains uncertain. While ownership has not yet made a statement regarding his status, a new GM could mean a complete reset of the coaching staff.
The New York Giants are at a crossroads. The decision to part ways with Joe Schoen marks the beginning of a new era—one that will determine whether this historic franchise can return to glory or continue its downward spiral.
As the search for a new GM begins, fans and analysts will be watching closely to see who will be entrusted with restoring the Giants to championship contention. One thing is certain: Big changes are coming to East Rutherford.
